1300 082 011
HomeThe Evidence › Sugar Bananas, Lao PDR
Field trial · 2019–20 · Lao Department of Agriculture

Sugar bananas on TR1-affected ground — Xaythany

Four rates on cleared, verified infected ground, monitored for nine months by a government agronomist. Every plant in the untreated control died.

Background

A 50-hectare farm, verified affected

Fusarium wilt Tropical Race 1 has caused widespread losses on banana farms. This trial ran on a 50 hectare sugar banana farm at Ban Thong Mang in Xaythany District, verified as TR1-affected throughout, in co-operation with the Lao PDR Department of Agriculture.

Agronomist: Khonesavanh Chittarhat, Plant Protection Centre.

Method

The trial area was cleared of infected plants, contoured and fenced. Disease-free Pak Song seedlings were planted at 2 m spacing, rows 2 m apart. The area was divided into four equal parts:

TreatmentRate
T13 tonnes/ha
T22 tonnes/ha
T31 tonne/ha
T4Control — none

Ordinary commercial practice throughout. NPK 15:15:15 applied monthly at 150 g per plant on every lot. The Department of Agriculture and Plant Protection Centre collected the data — pests, diseases, stem and leaf growth, and typical TR1 indicators.

Growth data

Height (cm) and stem circumference (cm), recorded monthly:

MonthT1 — 3 t/haT2 — 2 t/haT3 — 1 t/haT4 — control
136.4 / 14.131.6 / 14.129.1 / 12.727.4 / 11.4
298.4 / 26.672.5 / 21.194.5 / 26.6
3140.0 / 40.1137.3 / 38.8136.9 / 38.4
5176.3 / 55.8164.5 / 53.0170.0 / 56.9
9187.0 / 50.0177.0 / 48.7176.0 / 50.0

Height / circumference. The control column ends at month one because all plants had died.

Results

Plants in T1, T2 and T3 showed no signs of TR1 through the trial. Black spot and yellow sigatoka were both noted — the trial did not make those go away.

All plants in the untreated control lot died.

T1, at 3 tonnes per hectare, gave the strongest growth and plant health.

How to read this result

This records what a government agronomist observed on four lots over nine months: growth measurements, and the presence or absence of typical TR1 indicators. The Black Stuff is a soil conditioner, not a fungicide, and is not registered as an agricultural chemical product.

The trial was concluded early in March 2020 by the nationwide Covid-19 lockdown, so it did not run to harvest. Black spot and yellow sigatoka were present on treated lots throughout.

The untreated control plot at Thongmang, where all bananas died
Control plot. All plants died.
Bananas treated at 3 tonnes per hectare at Thongmang
Treated at 3 t/ha.
Tropical Race 1 symptoms on a banana pseudostem
TR1 on the surrounding ground.
Talk to us Download the report (PDF)

Sugar banana TR1, Lao PDR 2019–2020 · 7 pp. The Black Stuff is a soil conditioner and is not a registered agricultural chemical product. Nothing in this report is a claim that it controls, prevents or treats any plant disease.

Trial data

Location — Ban Thong Mang, Xaythany District

Crop — sugar banana, Pak Song cultivar

Farm — 50 ha, verified TR1 affected

Soil — sandy loam, pH 4.5

Rainfall — 2,200 mm annual

Spacing — 2 m × 2 m

Nutrition — NPK 15:15:15, 150 g/plant monthly, all lots

Agronomist — Khonesavanh Chittarhat, PPC

Duration — 9 months, ended March 2020